There is a question here about whether men are entitled to have a view on women’s rights, or whether or view can even be relevant.
I believe anyone can have an opinion on anything. This is not ‘telling women what to do’ – believe me - I don’t have the power to tell anyone what to do. Further, I have views on all sorts of things that don’t directly affect me – on Palestine for example – but surely for feminism to work it should affect men, and if you are affected, you have a right to express a view. But in any case, if women talk about what it’s like to be a man, then surely men know more than women? And surely that information is useful? If the women’s rights campaign is based on outdated, faulty or simplistic ideas about men then it can’t possibly work as well as it should, and I want it to work as well as possible.
But, more importantly, women can’t expect to simply impose their view on men, any more than men can simply impose their view on women. Nobody is entitled to impose their view of the world on anyone else, and nobody should be expected to unquestioningly accept anyone else’s opinion. If you want people to change you have to persuade them – negotiate, compromise. This seems to be something modern ‘woke’ progressives have forgotten. They seem to think if they get angry people will do as they’re told, and if they don’t they’re fascists. I have genuinely had these sorts of conversations. I ask them “When was the last time you changed your mind because someone shouted at you or called you names?” They tell me that it makes them feel better but that’s just self-indulgent. If you’re not trying to change people’s minds you’re not trying to make things better – you’re just having a tantrum.
It’s been depressing to see how much women really don’t want to hear the other side of the debate – even when the conversation is explicitly about what men think or feel or want. Women don’t know what men really feel, think and want, anything like as much as they think they do, and they really don’t like to ask. (Men of course don’t pretend to know what women really feel, think, and want.) It is remarkable how often women have told me I’m thinking something that I know very well I’m not, and then tell me I’m lying if I say so. Somehow women really believe they know what’s going on in my head better than I do. If a man did that to a woman it would be called ‘gaslighting’.
As a result women have some very strange ideas about what it means to be a man. They say they’re tired of hearing from men, but we very rarely talk about how life is for us – how we feel, our problems. There is a vast body of women's literature - fact and fiction - detailing every possible experience of life as a woman - childhood, parenthood, work, education, relationships, sex, beauty, medicine and crime - tales of ordinary women coping with their everyday lives, but the men's literature is about super heroes and gangsters, cowboys and soldiers. Learned works by are academics, politicians, priests and writers – not your average man in the street. If not it's outsiders - criminals, soldiers, immigrants, gays and celebrities. The rest of us - the ordinary man in Lidl - are invisible. We keep it to ourselves. We bottle it up or get pissed and make a joke of it, or if things get too much we go nuts and scare every-one. There seems to be this imaginary ‘Man’ in the feminist mind – a well-paid executive in a suit – a boss basically - or maybe menacing no-neck BREXIT man – nothing at all like most of us ordinary blokes.
And yet we see normal blokes all the time - in the supermarket, at the pub, at work - sad, weedy, anxious, old, depressed, short, awkward, fat, shy or ugly people and we don't seem to realise that THAT is what ordinary men look like. We see our own insecurities and mistakes and embarrassments and yet we still think Men are cool and confident. These men we see in real life must surely be a mistake. They're not Men. They must be some sort of freakish losers. But no - that's us - that's what ordinary men are like. We just don't recognise them. It's a weird sort of cognitive dissonance. Men who are any-thing but powerful still insist that Men have all the power. Men who can barely make a living tell us 'it's a man's world'. I find this very strange.
The problem is that most men are NOT more powerful than women any more, and many of us are in serious trouble (suicide and homelessness are much higher in men) so this dynamic has become a problem. Women are putting men down when they're already down. Women are punching down when they think they're punching up. In less 'educated' (ie poor) communities this can lead to an angry backlash and polarisation."
The problem might be that the modern progressive movement are middle-class college kids and many of the poor working class are older, male and white. They’re rude and noisy and won’t do as they’re told. Modern progressives talk down to them and then are horrified when they vote conservative. I don’t condone it, but I’m not surprised.
No comments:
Post a Comment